Decoding the Thanksgiving Debate: Is Sweet Potato Casserole a Side Dish or Dessert?
As Thanksgiving approaches, a debate that often arises is whether sweet potato casserole is a side dish or a dessert. This delicious dish, with its creamy sweet potatoes and crunchy pecan topping, often straddles the line between the two categories. Some people argue that its sweetness and common use of marshmallows make it a dessert, while others insist that it’s a traditional side dish served alongside the turkey. Let’s delve into this debate and try to settle it once and for all.
The Case for Side Dish
Those who argue that sweet potato casserole is a side dish point to its history and traditional place on the Thanksgiving table. Sweet potatoes have been a part of Thanksgiving meals since the holiday’s inception, long before marshmallows were added to the mix. The dish is often served alongside the main course, not after it, which is a common characteristic of side dishes.
Historically, sweet potatoes were a staple food for Native Americans and were likely present at the first Thanksgiving.
The addition of marshmallows, which happened in the early 20th century, was a marketing ploy by marshmallow companies to increase sales.
Even with the addition of marshmallows, many families still serve sweet potato casserole alongside the turkey, not as a dessert.
The Case for Dessert
On the other hand, those who believe sweet potato casserole is a dessert point to its sweet flavor profile and common use of dessert ingredients like marshmallows and brown sugar. They argue that just because a dish is served with the main course doesn’t necessarily make it a side dish.
The sweetness of the dish, especially when marshmallows are included, aligns more with desserts than traditional savory side dishes.
Ingredients like brown sugar and pecans are commonly found in desserts.
Some people prefer to eat sweet potato casserole after the main course, like a dessert.
Conclusion: A Matter of Personal Preference
In the end, whether sweet potato casserole is a side dish or a dessert may come down to personal preference. Some families may prefer to serve it with the main course, while others may save it for dessert. What’s most important is that it’s a delicious part of your Thanksgiving meal, no matter when you choose to enjoy it.
So, as you prepare for your Thanksgiving feast, consider where sweet potato casserole fits best in your meal. Whether you serve it as a side dish or a dessert, it’s sure to be a hit with your guests.
